Founded in Michigan · Shipping to all 50 states · Instant online pricing
BrandMyJava

Comparison

Custom Cup Companies Compared: Minimums, Pricing and Lead Times

The short answer

Custom cup companies differ mainly in minimum order (from one case to tens of thousands of cups), how you get a price (online, instant, or by quote) and lead time (from about two weeks of production to 10 to 15 weeks). Match the supplier's minimum to your volume first, then compare landed price per cup and lead time.

Disclosure: BrandMyJava wrote this guide, and we're one of the suppliers in it. We've tried to say plainly who each option fits, including when another supplier is the better choice.

This is a reference table, not a ranking. It lists what each company publicly states about minimums, pricing and lead time so you can shortlist quickly. Everything was checked on the companies' own pages (or, where noted, reseller listings) in October 2026. Terms change: confirm before you order.

Minimums

Company Stated minimum Per
Your Brand Cafe One case (printed plastic cups) Order line
Hot Cup Factory Most custom orders from 1,000 units Size
HotShot Sleeves 1,000 (12 oz printed plastic cups) Size
Custacup 7,000 (PET and foam) Design
BrandMyJava 5,000 cup + lid sets (largest sizes 10,000) Size and design
Good Start Packaging Varies by product, often 10+ cases of 1,000 Product
noissue Listings show 10,000 and 50,000 unit options Product
Karat (Lollicup) Depends on product; resellers list 30,000 Order

How you get a price

Company Pricing
Your Brand Cafe Prices shown online
Hot Cup Factory Online, sold by the case
HotShot Sleeves Quote
Custacup Price ranges online for PET and foam; paper by quote
BrandMyJava Instant: build an order, price on the next screen
Good Start Packaging Online per product
Karat (Lollicup) Quote

Lead times

Company Stated lead time
HotShot Sleeves 10 days of production
Your Brand Cafe About 4 weeks on some paper cups; rush available
Custacup 4 to 5 weeks of production plus shipping (PET, foam)
noissue One listing shows 9 to 10 weeks delivery
Karat (Lollicup) 10 to 15 weeks (Lollicup support page)
BrandMyJava 5 to 7 weeks from the deposit; express shipping quoted by your rep

Lead times are usually counted from proof approval, not from your first email. Ask.

What they make

  • Double-wall hot cups: HotShot Sleeves, Hot Cup Factory, Good Start (compostable), BrandMyJava (kraft, 8 oz, 12 oz, 14 oz, 16 oz, 20 oz, 22 oz).
  • Clear cold cups: Your Brand Cafe, Hot Cup Factory, Custacup (PET), BrandMyJava (PET, 12 oz, 14 oz, 16 oz, 18 oz, 20 oz, 24 oz, 32 oz), Good Start (PLA).
  • Sleeves: HotShot Sleeves, Your Brand Cafe, Good Start (Java Jacket).
  • Bags and other packaging: noissue, Your Brand Cafe, BrandMyJava (logo bags, straws, napkins).

How to use this table

  1. Cross off suppliers whose minimum doesn't fit. If you use 50 cups a day of a size, a 30,000-cup run is years of stock; a one-case printer may suit you better.
  2. Get two or three quotes and convert each to a landed price per cup.
  3. Check lead time against your storage. Long lead times mean holding more stock.
  4. Ask the ten questions in how to choose a custom cup supplier.

Where BrandMyJava fits

We're one of the companies above. We fit shops and small chains with steady volume in their best-selling sizes, who want a price without waiting for a callback. We're not the cheapest option for a few hundred cups, and we don't compete with large manufacturers on 50,000-cup runs.

Frequently asked questions

Which custom cup company has the fastest turnaround?

Among those listed, HotShot Sleeves states 10 days of production. Always add shipping time and confirm when the clock starts.

Which custom cup companies show prices online?

Your Brand Cafe, Hot Cup Factory, Good Start Packaging and Custacup (for some cups) show prices online. BrandMyJava shows your exact price as soon as you build an order.

Why do minimums vary so much?

Different printing equipment. Small digital or short-run printers can do a case; large high-speed presses need tens of thousands of cups to be efficient.

See your price with your logo on it.

Build an order and your quote appears on the next screen. From 5,000 sets per size.

Get my price now

Keep reading